New customers take 20% Off (limited time) -Click Here!


Your Cart is Empty

March 17, 2023 3 min read


Pepper Jelly is a delicious condiment that marries the sweetness of sugar with the spicy kick of peppers, creating a unique and versatile flavor profile. The type of peppers used in a pepper jelly can significantly impact its heat level, flavor, and overall character. In this comprehensive guide, we'll explore the different types of peppers you can use to create your own unique pepper jelly, along with tips and suggestions for finding the perfect balance of sweet and spicy to suit your taste buds.

Green and red peppers - great for pepper jelly

I. Understanding Pepper Heat Levels

A. The Scoville scale

The heat level of a pepper is measured using the Scoville scale, which is based on the concentration of capsaicin, the compound responsible for a pepper's spiciness. The scale ranges from 0 Scoville Heat Units (SHU) for a bell pepper, which has no heat, up to over 2 million SHU for the world's hottest peppers.

Scoville Hot Peppers Scale

B. Balancing heat and flavor

When selecting peppers for your pepper jelly, consider both the heat level and the flavor profile of the pepper. Some peppers have a fruity, smoky, or earthy taste that can add depth and complexity to your jelly. You can also mix and match different types of peppers to create a unique flavor combination and a heat level that suits your preferences.

II. Popular Peppers for Pepper Jelly

A. Mild to medium heat peppers

For a milder pepper jelly with a touch of heat, consider using some of the following peppers:

  1. Bell peppers (0 SHU) – Sweet and mild, available in various colors, such as green, red, yellow, and orange.
  2. Banana peppers (0-500 SHU) – Mildly spicy with a slightly sweet flavor.
  3. Anaheim peppers (500-2,500 SHU) – Mild heat with a tangy, slightly sweet taste.
  4. Poblano peppers (1,000-2,000 SHU) – Mild to medium heat with an earthy flavor.
  5. Jalapeño peppers (2,500-8,000 SHU) – Medium heat with a bright, slightly sweet flavor.

Jalapeño peppers

B. Medium to hot peppers

For a spicier pepper jelly, consider using some of the following peppers:

  1. Serrano peppers (10,000-23,000 SHU) – Medium to hot heat with a bright, slightly fruity flavor.
  2. Cayenne peppers (30,000-50,000 SHU) – Hot heat with a sharp, pungent flavor.
  3. Thai bird's eye chilies (50,000-100,000 SHU) – Hot heat with a fruity, slightly smoky taste.
  4. Habanero peppers (100,000-350,000 SHU) – Very hot heat with a fruity, citrusy flavor.
  5. Scotch bonnet peppers (100,000-350,000 SHU) – Very hot heat with a sweet, fruity taste.

Hot Peppers

III. Creating Your Custom Pepper Jelly Blend

A. Experimenting with flavor combinations

Don't be afraid to get creative when making your pepper jelly. You can mix and match different types of peppers, or even incorporate additional fruits, herbs, or spices to create a unique and flavorful jelly. Some ideas to get you started include:

    1. Pineapple-habanero pepper jelly
    2. Raspberry-jalapeño pepper jelly
    3. Mango-serrano pepper jelly
    4. Roasted red pepper and garlic jelly
    5. Chipotle-lime pepper jelly

Various pepper jelly combinations

    1. B. Adjusting heat levels

      To create the perfect heat level for your pepper jelly, adjust the ratio of spicy peppers to mild peppers or bell peppers. For a milder jelly, use a higher proportion of bell peppers or other mild peppers; for a spicier jelly, use more hot peppers like jalapeños or habaneros. You can also remove the seeds and membranes from the peppers to reduce their heat level.

      Various pepper spice levels

      IV. Tips for Making and Enjoying Your Pepper Jelly

      A. Safety precautions

      When handling hot peppers, be sure to wear gloves and avoid touching your eyes or face. The capsaicin in the peppers can cause irritation or burning. Wash your hands thoroughly after handling peppers, and clean all surfaces and utensils used during the preparation process.

      B. Serving suggestions

      Once you've created your custom pepper jelly, enjoy it in a variety of ways:

      1. Serve it as a topping for cream cheese or goat cheese on crackers or toasted bread.
      2. Use it as a glaze for grilled meats, such as pork, chicken, or even salmon.
      3. Add it to a sandwich or burger for a sweet and spicy kick.
      4. Drizzle it over roasted vegetables or mix it into a salad dressing.
      5. Incorporate it into a dessert, such as a cheesecake or a chocolate tart.

Mango Pepper Jelly Chicken


Creating your own unique pepper jelly blend is a fun and rewarding process that allows you to explore different flavors, heat levels, and pepper combinations. With this guide to understanding and selecting the perfect peppers for your jelly, you'll be well on your way to creating a delicious and versatile condiment that you can enjoy in a variety of dishes. So grab your gloves and start experimenting with different peppers to create your own sweet and spicy masterpiece!

Traditional Pepper Jelly breakfast

Be creative! Include Pepper Jelly in a variety of chicken, fish, and fish meals or add it as a spread, dip, or glaze for all your meals.