Pepper Jelly Pairings

Pair pepper jelly with foods that give its sweetness, tang and pepper flavor something to complement. Cheese and crackers are the familiar starting point, but meat, seafood, sandwiches and breakfast dishes give you other ways to use a jar. Choose a food category below, then follow the detailed guide for specific combinations.

Cheese, crackers and boards

Meat and seafood

Choose meat and poultry pairings or seafood pairings for the broader categories. For more specific fruit-flavor choices, explore Cranberry Pepper Jelly protein pairings and Pomegranate Pepper Jelly protein pairings.

When you need cooking quantities and a full method, use a recipe rather than a pairing suggestion. The chicken and turkey recipe hub and seafood recipe hub help you continue in that direction.

Breakfast and sweet foods

Explore breakfast and brunch recipes or dessert recipes when you want a sweet-and-savory pairing beyond an appetizer board. The same flavor can work differently as a small topping, a pastry filling or part of a cooked dish.

Choose heat and flavor separately

A smoky flavor is not automatically the hottest choice, and fruit flavor does not automatically mean low heat. In Grandma Jones’ lineup, Southwestern Chipotle is Medium, Cranberry is Mild and Cranberry Habanero is Hot. Use Find Your Flavor to compare all eight.

For a mixed group, offer the jelly separately so each person controls the amount. Once you have chosen your pairings, shop all eight Grandma Jones’ Pepper Jelly flavors to select the jars for your menu.

Take a pairing idea into a complete salad

A cold salad can bring a different texture to a meal built around glazed food. Lentil salad with Dijon dressing uses a measured small jelly addition, while cucumber and dill salad includes draining and dressing steps to limit excess liquid. Pair them with a main whose sweetness does not overwhelm the whole meal.

For a whole-bean salad rather than a creamy dip, butter bean salad with lemon dressing combines ready-to-eat canned beans with crisp vegetables and lemon dressing. Keep it chilled; the acidic dressing is a flavor choice, not a preservation method.

Serve food alongside whiskey

The whiskey food-pairing guide starts with a small cheese-and-cracker plate and a separate jelly portion. This differs from dissolving jelly into a cocktail. Compare one bite at a time, keep Hot flavors clearly identified, and offer water and a nonalcoholic choice. The guide does not claim ranked tasting results.

A practical food-pairing chart

Use this chart to choose a starting combination. These are editorial serving suggestions, not results from a comparative tasting test. The complete bite matters: cheese, salt, acid and texture can change how prominent the jelly seems.

Food Starting flavor direction How to keep the bite balanced
Creamy cheese and crackers Traditional with cream cheese; Cranberry with Brie Keep the jelly layer small and use a crisp base.
Firm or smoked cheese Jalapeño with cheddar; Southwestern Chipotle with Gouda Avoid stacking smoky meat, smoked cheese and smoky jelly unless that intensity is deliberate.
Poultry and pork Cranberry with turkey; Traditional with ham Use a separately portioned sauce or the late glaze from a complete recipe.
Fish and shellfish Caribbean Mango with shrimp; Pomegranate with salmon Add citrus to the measured sauce and keep the fish exposed rather than heavily covered.
Eggs and breakfast breads Traditional with eggs or biscuits; Pomegranate with toast Choose one sweet accent; reduce competing syrup or sweet toppings.
Vegetables and beans Cranberry with braised cabbage; Chipotle with lentils Build the savory base first, then add the recipe’s measured jelly finish.
Dessert or fruit Caribbean Mango with pineapple; Cranberry in a pastry filling Use a recipe written for the filling or topping; do not substitute a thin meat glaze.

Build and adjust one bite

Choose a savory or neutral base, a contrasting texture and one jelly. Taste a small assembled bite. If too sweet, reduce the jelly portion or choose a less sweet base. If too intense, start a new bite with a Mild flavor; diluting a Hot jelly also changes consistency and does not remove its chile ingredients. For a richer bite, try a little acid or a crisp vegetable alongside rather than automatically adding another sweet condiment.

Sweet and savory are serving directions, not fixed jelly categories. The same Cranberry jelly can accompany salty ham or fill a cookie. Decide whether the meal needs a savory contrast or a dessert filling, then follow the appropriate complete method.

Pair apples or pears without soaking the base

For a cold bite, use a firm washed apple or pear slice with cheddar, Brie or goat cheese and a small dab of Traditional or Cranberry Pepper Jelly. These are suggested combinations, not taste-test rankings. Slice close to serving; keep fruit juices away from crackers and toast until assembly. The fruit already supplies sweetness, so begin with less jelly than you might put on a plain cheese bite.

For cooked apples, follow the apple galette method rather than treating a cold pairing as a pastry formula. The fruit cooks first and receives a thin jelly glaze afterward. Pears vary in ripeness and moisture, so they are not an automatic same-time substitution in that apple recipe.

A Secret Recipe Exclusively for Family and Friends

From her home on the corner of Seminary Place and Murray Street in Forty Fort, Pennsylvania Marcia Jones (Grandma Jones) hosted countless family gatherings, holiday dinners, and bridge club get-togethers with friends. While food was always plentiful and delicious, family and friends most looked forward to gaining exclusive access to a limited supply of Marcia’s cherished family recipe of “Pepper Jam.”

Buy Pepper Jelly

Something Unique. Incredibly Special.

Pepper Jam is a unique blend of sweet, sour, and spicy that can be served traditionally alongside cheese and crackers or be used as a gourmet spread, dip, or glaze to enhance any meal. Once you buy Pepper Jam you’ll likely end up purchasing it on a regular basis just like you would ketchup, salt and pepper, or steak sauce. It’s that diverse and delicious.

Buy Pepper Jelly

Going Global - QVC Pepper Jam Premier

In 1999 Marcia’s grandson’s – Richard Jones III (Penn Lake, PA) and Kristopher Jones (Shavertown, PA) decided to take their Grandmother’s recipe, bottle it up, and share it with the world via e-commerce. Kris’s role in the company was head of Internet marketing, while Rick was head of product development and manufacturing. The pepperjam.com website was launched in late 1999 and the company began taking orders.

In early 2000 Rick, Kris, and their sister Jennifer attended the Fancy Food Gourmet Food Show in New York City where they met QVC Celebrity Chef Jorge Bruce. During that encounter Jennifer insisted Chef Jorge try Grandma Jones’ Pepper Jam. He loved it, which eventually led to Chef Jorge writing a 150+ recipe Pepper Jam cookbook and helping the company take Grandma Jones Pepper Jam on QVC.

As Kris remembers it, “Debuting Pepper Jam on QVC was surreal. It felt like we won a Super Bowl commercial. In less than 4 minutes we not only sold thousands of jars of product, but we affirmed that there is something very special about Grandma Jones Pepper Jam.”

Grandma Jones’ Pepper Jam continues to be sold online and at select brick and mortar locations throughout the United States.

It remains our pleasure to offer you limited access to our Grandmother’s cherished recipes.

Kristopher and Robyn Jones
Rick and Melanie Jones
Jennifer and Jonathan Runquist