Pepper Jelly Dessert Recipes
Pepper jelly can become a pastry filling, a ribbon through bread pudding or a topping for a dessert. Start with a recipe written for the type of dessert you want to make. A filled yeast doughnut, a hand pie and a baked custard each require a different method, even when all three use pepper jelly.
Choose a complete dessert recipe
- Cranberry Pepper Jelly Bread Pudding — brioche and vanilla custard with cranberry pepper jelly and a serving sauce.
- Pomegranate Pepper Jelly Doughnuts — yeast-raised, fried doughnuts filled after cooking.
- Mango Pepper Jelly Hand Pies — individual pastries with a fruit-forward pepper jelly filling.
Looking for topping and serving ideas?
The guide to pepper jelly in desserts covers more ways to pair sweet foods with pepper jelly. Use it for inspiration when choosing a topping for ice cream, cheesecake or another prepared dessert. Use a complete recipe when you need dough, custard or baking instructions.
For breakfast-style baking alongside a dessert spread, see pepper jelly cornbread muffins and our breakfast and brunch recipes. Cornbread muffins serve a different role from a sweet pastry, so choose according to the meal you are planning.
Choose the fruit and heat separately
Caribbean Mango, Cranberry and Pomegranate are all in Grandma Jones’ Mild category. Cranberry Habanero is a separate Hot flavor; do not assume two cranberry-named jars will deliver the same pepper finish. Visit Find Your Flavor to compare the complete lineup.
Bake Sandwich Cookies or Make Chocolate Truffles
- Cranberry Pepper Jelly Linzer Cookies — Almond sandwich cookies with chilled cutout dough and cranberry filling.
- Pepper Jelly Chocolate Truffles — Cocoa-dusted dark chocolate ganache with a small amount of pepper jelly.
Bake Brownies With a Pepper Jelly Swirl
- Pepper Jelly Brownies With a Sweet-Heat Swirl — A full from-scratch brownie method with measured jelly swirls and doneness checks.
Before using jelly as a filling
Follow the amount and placement in the selected recipe. More filling is not automatically better: the method should account for how the pastry is sealed, how the dough is cooked and when the jelly is added. A doughnut filled after frying needs a different approach from a pie filled before baking.
Read the individual recipe’s cooling and storage instructions, especially for desserts containing eggs, milk, cream or cheese.
When you have chosen your dessert, shop all eight Grandma Jones’ Pepper Jelly flavors to find the pepper jelly called for in the recipe.
Choose when the jelly enters the bake
For cookies filled after cooling, the jelly is a finishing ingredient. For hand pies or brownie swirls, it changes the bake itself. Read baking with pepper jelly before choosing between those methods: it covers filling consistency, dry pastry seams, exposed sugar and why jelly cannot replace an equal volume of butter or eggs. Compare Traditional versus Cranberry when deciding between a classic pepper direction and a Mild fruit accent.
A warm fruit option without pastry
Skillet pineapple with mango jelly and lime browns fresh fruit before adding a brief finish. It needs neither a dough nor an egg binder. Serve any ice cream or yogurt separately and account for its ingredients and refrigeration. Canned fruit in syrup will not behave like the fresh wedges specified in the recipe.
Make an open apple tart
Apple galette with Cranberry Pepper Jelly uses a chilled butter crust, thin apple slices and a folded border. Bake the fruit and crust before brushing on a thin jelly glaze. If the dough becomes greasy while rolling, chill it again. The open format and fruit moisture differ from sealed cream-cheese hand pies, so keep their filling quantities and baking times separate.
A Secret Recipe Exclusively for Family and Friends
From her home on the corner of Seminary Place and Murray Street in Forty Fort, Pennsylvania Marcia Jones (Grandma Jones) hosted countless family gatherings, holiday dinners, and bridge club get-togethers with friends. While food was always plentiful and delicious, family and friends most looked forward to gaining exclusive access to a limited supply of Marcia’s cherished family recipe of “Pepper Jam.”
Something Unique. Incredibly Special.
Pepper Jam is a unique blend of sweet, sour, and spicy that can be served traditionally alongside cheese and crackers or be used as a gourmet spread, dip, or glaze to enhance any meal. Once you buy Pepper Jam you’ll likely end up purchasing it on a regular basis just like you would ketchup, salt and pepper, or steak sauce. It’s that diverse and delicious.
Going Global - QVC Pepper Jam Premier
In 1999 Marcia’s grandson’s – Richard Jones III (Penn Lake, PA) and Kristopher Jones (Shavertown, PA) decided to take their Grandmother’s recipe, bottle it up, and share it with the world via e-commerce. Kris’s role in the company was head of Internet marketing, while Rick was head of product development and manufacturing. The pepperjam.com website was launched in late 1999 and the company began taking orders.
In early 2000 Rick, Kris, and their sister Jennifer attended the Fancy Food Gourmet Food Show in New York City where they met QVC Celebrity Chef Jorge Bruce. During that encounter Jennifer insisted Chef Jorge try Grandma Jones’ Pepper Jam. He loved it, which eventually led to Chef Jorge writing a 150+ recipe Pepper Jam cookbook and helping the company take Grandma Jones Pepper Jam on QVC.
As Kris remembers it, “Debuting Pepper Jam on QVC was surreal. It felt like we won a Super Bowl commercial. In less than 4 minutes we not only sold thousands of jars of product, but we affirmed that there is something very special about Grandma Jones Pepper Jam.”
Grandma Jones’ Pepper Jam continues to be sold online and at select brick and mortar locations throughout the United States.
It remains our pleasure to offer you limited access to our Grandmother’s cherished recipes.
Kristopher and Robyn Jones
Rick and Melanie Jones
Jennifer and Jonathan Runquist